Fact-checking 'Twisters': Can tornadoes really be stopped with science? (2024)

Spoiler alert! We're discussing important plot points and the ending of this summer's tornado-chasing thriller "Twisters" (in theaters now), so blow on down the road if you haven't seen it yet.

"Twisters" has twin interwoven storylines driving the mayhem forward.

One is the tension-filled chemistry between the disaster movie's protagonists, dueling storm chasers Kate Carter (Daisy Edgar-Jones) and Tyler Owens (Glen Powell). The actors bring a totally believable zip to the brewing relationship.

The other is Kate's lifelong obsession with figuring out how to use science to make a raging tornado literally vanish into thin air. And on that count, we have largely ventured into the realm of the improbable.

Join our Watch Party!Sign up to receive USA TODAY's movie and TV recommendations right in your inbox

Need a break? Play the USA TODAY Daily Crossword Puzzle.

Fact-checking 'Twisters': Can tornadoes really be stopped with science? (1)

Kevin Kelleher was a tornado consultant both on director Lee Isaac Chung's Oklahoma-rooted tale as well as Jan de Bont's 1996 original "Twister." Kelleher spent most of his career at the National Severe Storms Laboratory in Norman, Oklahoma.

The first film focused on deploying tiny flying balls into a tornado to better understand the DNA of that windy phenomenon. "It was accurate except for the fact that we didn't have tiny computers that could fit in small balls 30 years ago," he says.

Can you make a tornado vanish like in 'Twisters'? Only theoretically, expert says

Kelleher says that while it's now conceivable to replicate the tech in "Twister," that's not the case for "Twisters."

In the updated version, Kate's brainstorm involves chasing a massive tornado and performing a timed release of a few dozen big canisters of chemicals into the updraft, which reacts with the moisture in the funnel and eventually causes it to weaken and disappear.

Fact-checking 'Twisters': Can tornadoes really be stopped with science? (2)

Such tech would obviously be a boon to those communities that suffer damage and loss of life every year at the hand of tornados, largely Midwestern and Southern states. The science is technically sound.

"There are chemicals that can absorb water, and as we know, moisture and rain is a fuel for thunderstorms," Kelleher says. "Theoretically, if you remove moisture, you diminish the effects of a tornado."

That is indeed what we see in "Twisters" as Daisy single-handedly defuses a massive tornado as it's about to level a nearby town. She does so by driving a pickup into the path of the storm and dramatically popping the tops off her chemicals, watching as they get sucked into the vortex and, ultimately, neutralize the threat.

Unfortunately, Kelleher says, what we see in "Twisters" is not possible − for now.

"It's a matter of scale, really," he says, adding tornado experts agree that “to have any sort of effect remotely like this, you'd likely need 22,000 tons of this stuff, which you obviously couldn't just back onto a pickup truck's trailer and drive into a storm. So it's pretty science fiction at this point."

Radar panels that detect a tornado's shape exist, but are they as portable as 'Twisters' shows?

There's another high-tech component to "Twisters" that's worthy of inquiry. It involves a second group of storm chasers led by Javi (Anthony Ramos) who are trying to get more data by quickly surrounding the moving funnels with three door-sized radar panels that use triangulated data to conjure a computer-generated image of the tornado's structure.

In the movie, Javi and his team jump out of their trucks and within seconds pop their radar shields into place. Does such equipment exist? Yes and no. Again, it's about scale.

"For the movie, they basically miniaturized the radar (shields)," Kelleher says. "There really are devices that can (take images of tornado shapes), but to hop in and out of vans like that with them, no way. And they forgot that each one needs its own generator."

Fact-checking 'Twisters': Can tornadoes really be stopped with science? (4)

Kelleher says tornado science is an ever-evolving pursuit of data on a quirk of nature that repeatedly defies full understanding. The minute you think a tornado is about to form and touch down, it will vanish. And vice versa, as blue skies seem to morph into a menacing horizon in mere moments.

But given the lives and property damage at stake, the research into understanding this elusive phenomenon will continue, no matter how daunting the task, he says. Even small jumps in knowledge can lead to earlier warnings that might cut death tolls.

In the end, "Mother Nature is powerful, and we are not. Our ability to influence and change the weather is minimal."

Fact-checking 'Twisters': Can tornadoes really be stopped with science? (2024)

FAQs

Fact-checking 'Twisters': Can tornadoes really be stopped with science? ›

In real life, up to 30 tons of material would be needed to cause any meaningful change in an environment as powerful as a tornado. “It's physically not possible,” Dr. Waugh said.

Can you stop a tornado like in Twisters? ›

In real life, scientists conclude it would take an incredible amount of the chemical used in the movie to have a real effect on destabilizing a tornado.

Can a tornado be stopped? ›

Brooks said even if we did stop a tornado, the storm around it would likely just produce another tornado. In effect, stopping a tornado and not dealing with the storm around it is like chopping off the head of a hydra -- another will reappear shortly.

Was the science in Twisters real? ›

The first film focused on deploying tiny flying balls into a tornado to better understand the DNA of that windy phenomenon. "It was accurate except for the fact that we didn't have tiny computers that could fit in small balls 30 years ago," he says.

Were the tornadoes in twister real? ›

During post-production of Twister, Spielberg took over directing duties on Minority Report instead of The Haunting, which ultimately was directed by de Bont. The tornadoes in the film were created with computer animation.

Is Twisters scientifically accurate? ›

Our scientists worked hard behind the scenes with the producers to make the science as accurate and realistic (in some parts!) as possible,” the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) said in a blog post coinciding with the movie's release last Friday.

What can resist a tornado? ›

Homes built with insulated concrete forms (ICF), like Fox Blocks, maintain their integrity during the high winds of a tornado. Insulating concrete forms can withstand winds of over 200 mph.

Can cold air stop a tornado? ›

Even in cases where the air in the area of ongoing tornadic activity is not cooled enough to instantly extinguish the tornado (or where the tornado is very large), cold air intake is likely to weaken/slow the tornado.

How does a tornado finally stop? ›

Why and when does a tornado stop? There is no clear answer to this question. Scientists believe that a tornado stops because the spinning air in the funnel cloud gets too cold and thus the tornado loses its energy and dissipates.

Has a tornado ever killed? ›

Deadliest single tornado in US history

The Tri-State tornado of March 18, 1925, killed 695 people in Missouri (11), Illinois (613), and Indiana (71). The outbreak it occurred with was also the deadliest known tornado outbreak, with a combined death toll of 747 across the Mississippi River Valley.

Can you survive a twister? ›

Freak accidents happen; and the most violent tornadoes can level and blow away almost any house and its occupants. Extremely violent EF5 tornadoes are very rare, though. Even violent tornadoes have a survival rate of at least 99%. Most tornadoes are actually much weaker, and can be survived using these safety ideas...

Why tornado is called Twister? ›

The answer should be obvious: a tornado is a very focused, very rapidly turning cyclonic storm in which the air “twists” around and around in a rotary cloud of extreme low pressure.

What did the final tornado not destroy in Twister? ›

The last twister in the movie was classified and deemed an F-5, yet when it hits the farm where Jo and Bill are strapped to the pipe, about a third of the barn is still standing and the house can be seen more or less fully intact.

What's stronger a tornado or twister? ›

Tornado and twister are different names for the same type of storm—a violently rotating column of air over land associated with a severe thunderstorm. Tornadoes range in diameter from metres to hundreds of metres and generally last from a few seconds up to half an hour.

Are double tornadoes real? ›

Usually when there are two tornadoes on the ground simultaneously, there is one stronger tornado and one tornado that is much weaker and usually the weaker one rotates around the parent tornado. Both of these twin tornadoes were very large and destructive.

What did twister get wrong? ›

In the movie, several vehicles get in and near tornadoes and emerge without much damage. In reality, flying debris can break windshields and kill or injure people, Walton said. Walton has concerns about the newest generation of chasers being unsafe.

Can tornadoes also be called Twisters? ›

A tornado is forming. Also known as twisters, tornadoes are violently spinning, funnel-shaped columns of air that stretch from the dark thunderclouds they form in all the way to the ground.

Is there an ending to Twisters? ›

Fans have lauded the chemistry between male star Powell and Edgar-Jones in the tornado tale, whose characters bond over their love — and fear — of disastrous weather in the rural depths of Oklahoma. But in the final scene, as they reunite before Kate bids farewell at the airport, the pair decidedly walk away together.

Can you stop a tornado with cold air? ›

Even in cases where the air in the area of ongoing tornadic activity is not cooled enough to instantly extinguish the tornado (or where the tornado is very large), cold air intake is likely to weaken/slow the tornado.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Stevie Stamm

Last Updated:

Views: 5878

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Stevie Stamm

Birthday: 1996-06-22

Address: Apt. 419 4200 Sipes Estate, East Delmerview, WY 05617

Phone: +342332224300

Job: Future Advertising Analyst

Hobby: Leather crafting, Puzzles, Leather crafting, scrapbook, Urban exploration, Cabaret, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is Stevie Stamm, I am a colorful, sparkling, splendid, vast, open, hilarious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.